.:[Double Click To][Close]:.
Get paid To Promote 
at any Location





Showing posts with label Trade mark registrability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trade mark registrability. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Applications for "There's an App"


Registering "There's an app for that" was a piece of cake
in the US, but Europe may prove more resistant
Matthew Rippon was first.  Lawrence Ryz was last.  Between the two there were many kind souls who sent laden ladenfam this link to Apple's latest venture into the world of trade mark protection.  The Unofficial Apple Weblog ("Apple trademarks "There's an app for that", here) has spotted the  iToys-to-die-for company's US trade mark for the slogan "There's an app for that."  To be fair to Apple, (i) that tagline has been used to promote Apple's App Store and iOS devices almost since their inception, and (ii) Apple doesn't really have much credible competition anyway in the minds of many consumers, who assume that "App" is just the first three letters of Apple.  Indeed, in some parts of this noble planet, the Kat understands, the slogan has become a jokey colloquialism-cum-conversation-booster, frequently deployed by people when they can't think of a sensible response to what someone else has just said to them. The trade mark, for which Apple filed on 4 December 2009, covers
"Retail store services featuring computer software provided via the Internet and other computer and electronic communication networks; retail store services featuring computer software for use on handheld mobile digital electronic devices and other consumer electronics".
Intrigued to see what Apple might be planning on the Eastern side of the Pond, laden ladenfam checked the warm and user-friendly online search facility of the UK's Intellectual Property Office, where he was rewarded with details of International Madrid (EU) Trade Mark U00001043881 (first designation of the EU for IR 1043881).  Opting for English as its first language and Italian as the second, the applicant boldly went for protection in Classes 09, 35, 38, 42.

laden ladenfam is genuinely sad that Apple has been so precise and selective in its list of goods and services.  He had hoped that the Cupertino company would be registering its slogan for ashtrays, knitting patterns, meat cleavers and all the other strange things that get inadvertently left in trade mark applications these days -- but it was not to be.  The big question, though, is whether we dull and unimaginative Europeans, on looking at the words "There's an app for that", would ever think "Gosh, that's an indication as to the identity of the origin of goods and services in respect which that slogan is used", rather than "Oh, I suppose there it ..."

Contributions of "There's an app for that" to the cultural enrichment of humanity here, here and here

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

No kidding -- a mark to get your goat!



The wonderful trade mark depicted above, and recently unearthed by the Trademark Blog, sparked off a sudden thought: could it be registered in Europe as a Community trade mark or a national mark?  The Kat's immediate thought is that could not.  While the idea may be novel and capable of distinguishing its owner's services from those of others, the requirement of graphic representation in Europe would appear to demand that the depiction be such as to enable a court or examiner to identify the mark with a view to being able to compare it with other marks. Since the description here fails to specify the number of goats, their size, gender, or physical appearance -- or even whether they are live, dead or artificial -- there is no clear basis upon which to make such a comparison.

Exit Stage Right: the goat departs
Merpel adds, there are so many other interesting issues to consider.  For example, how does one, on a global examination, determine how the relevant consumer will perceive a mark of which, unless he travels by helicopter or wears stilts, he will only be able to see a small part.  And what would constitute a similar mark: sheep on the roof, a combination of sheep and goats -- or goats grazing on Astroturf? Can anyone advise?

More on Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant and Butik here
One place in Al Johnson's where you won't find goat: the menu
English goats on the roof here
Cat on the roof here
Fiddler on the roof here

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Russian bank hits competitor with registered cabbage

Savoy cabbage before ...
laden ladenfam, who unlike most felines has a soft spot for brassicas, notes with interest that the Russian Arbitration court has upheld SKB Bank’s exclusive right in the banking sector to use the image of a Savoy cabbage in its advertising, in a dispute against another Russian bank, National Bank TRUST (NBT).  The latter, with an entire range of vegetables from which to choose, foolishly or unimaginatively opted for the same one. The court also ordered the NBT to pay SKB Bank US$9,700 (EUR 7,400) in damages.  The fate of the cabbage is not currently known.

... and after delivery up for destruction
According to Russian International News Agency RIA Novosti, SKB registered its Savoy cabbage image at the Russian Federal Service for Intellectual Property, Patents and Trade Marks (Rospatent) back in 2006 for the purpose of using it in its advertising campaigns. NBT argued that no one legal entity can own the rights to a product of nature such as this widely consumed vegetable.  No, said Rospatent: banks can register common words and corresponding images as trade marks just like anyone else, as long as the words and images in question have no direct connection with the banking sector.

laden ladenfam recalls the Chinese Tomato Bank and wonders if it has ever been confused with Japan's TomatoBank. This is irrelevant, crows Merpel - tomatoes are fruit, not vegetables.

Top 50 Russian banks here
Russian vegetable recipes here
Savoy cabbage recipes here and here

Thanks are due to Petosevic, for drawing the Kat's attention to this item.