.:[Double Click To][Close]:.
Get paid To Promote 
at any Location





Showing posts with label Australia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Australia. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Is that AFACT? Copyright federation pursues its quarry to High Court

Secondary liability on the internet is definitely the flavour of the month. Yesterday night laden ladenfam reported on the liability of a search engine for contributory infringement of copyright -- and this morning the spotlight turns on Australia, where the question whether internet service providers (ISPs) are liable for the acts of their subscribers is set to get the country's top judges scratching their heads as they seek the right answer.  Thanks to the Kat's friend Catherine M Lee, this weblog can bring you the following information:
"Are Australian ISPs liable for the copyright infringements of their subscribers? The High Court, the top court in Australia, may soon be asked to give an answer.

Proceedings between 34 members of AFACT (the Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft) and the ISP iiNet (the third largest ISP in Australia) have been ongoing for over two years and attracted considerable interest in Australia and overseas. AFACT had investigated copyright infringement occurring by means of a peer-to-peer system known as the BitTorrent protocol by subscribers and users of iiNet’s services. The information generated from these investigations was then sent to iiNet by AFACT, with a demand that iiNet take action to stop the infringements occurring, though the measures AFACT asked iiNet to take were not clearly stated. iiNet failed to take any steps to stop infringing conduct. Did this mean that iiNet had authorised the copyright infringement of certain users?

In November 2008, numerous AFACT members commenced legal proceedings against iiNet. The case came before Cowdroy J sitting in the Federal Court, commencing in October 2009 and lasting for 20 days. In February 2010, Cowdroy J found that iiNet did not authorise the infringements of copyright of the iiNet users. His Honour reached this conclusion following three primary findings: 
1. the mere provision of access to the internet was not the ‘means’ of authorising infringement. Rather, the ‘means’ by which the AFACT members’ copyright is infringed is an iiNet user’s use of the constituent parts of the BitTorrent system, something over which iiNet has no control or responsibility.
2. a scheme for notification, suspension and termination of customer accounts was not (in this instance) a relevant power to prevent copyright infringement or a reasonable step to take.
3. iiNet simply cannot be seen as sanctioning, approving or countenancing copyright infringement: iiNet has done no more than to provide an internet service to its users.
The AFACT members appealed to the Full Federal Court. This appeal was dismissed by the majority (Nicholas and Emmett JJ, Jagot J dissenting) in February 2011. However despite this, the AFACT members ended up in a stronger position than they were following the first instance decision of Cowdroy J. The main reasons for this were that: 
1. Emmett J in effect also ruled that, in certain circumstances, ISPs would be obliged to act on infringement notices when provided with ‘unequivocal and cogent evidence of the alleged primary acts of infringement by use of the … service in question’ or be considered to have authorised infringement (at [210]).
2. All the justices agreed that iiNet could not protect itself by claiming that it was a "Safe Harbour" for it did not have a policy to deal which allowed for termination of repeat infringers in appropriate circumstances (Emmett J at [272], Jagot J at [524], Nicholas J at [803]).
Nonetheless, on Thursday 24 March 2011, the members of AFACT indicated that they would seek leave to appeal to the High Court. In a press release issued on behalf of the Australian and US film studios, AFACT Executive Director Neil Gane suggested that the appeal would make the case that the Full Federal Court had incorrectly applied the legal test for authorisation and that iiNet did have sufficient knowledge of the acts of infringement committed by its subscribers.  iiNet's response to this move, reflected in its own media release of the same date, is that more litigation is not a solution and that it is time for the studios to work with the internet industry to make their works more readily and cheaply available online".
laden ladenfam looks forward to a High Court decision on the thorny issue of the responsibility for ISPs for copyright infringement committed by their subscribers in light of the new ISP provisions in the Copyright Act 1968 introduced as a result of the Australia-US Free Trade Agreement. Merpel however wonders whether it is a task for parliament and not the courts to make downloaders accountable for their infringing actions without imposing burdensome requirements on ISPs.

Sources
First instance ruling in Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd [2010] FCA 24 (4 February 2010) here
Appeal decision in Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd [2011] FCAFC 23 (24 February 2011) here

Friday, March 25, 2011

Coming to their Sensis: of Aussies, scams and the Yellow Peril

Scams of one sort or another have been frequent visitors to laden ladenfam's weblog recently.  Here's one all the way from Australia.  laden ladenfam thanks David Lancaster (Rouse Legal) for this note.  David acted for Sensis and Telstra.
Sensis Pty Ltd., Telstra Corporation Limited v Yellow Page Marketing B.V, WIPO Case No. D2011-0057 (here)
In Australia, the ‘Yellow Pages’ business directory is marketed and sold by Sensis Pty Ltd. Sensis is the exclusive licensee of numerous Australian trade mark registrations relating to Yellow Pages and the Walking Fingers Device, all of which are owned by Telstra Corporation Limited, Sensis being a wholly owned subsidiary of Telstra.
In May of last year, Sensis became aware of a scam operated by two companies -- Yellow Publishing Limited (an English company) and Yellow Page Marketing BV (‘YPM’), a Dutch company. These companies sent infringing faxes to Australian businesses, deceiving them into paying for registration with their ‘Yellow Page’ directory. YPM had also registered a number of domain names of the form ‘yellowpage-[location].com’, where the location was an Australian city or state (for example yellowpage-melbourne.com). 
Sensis I
Shortly after becoming aware of the scam, Telstra/Sensis (the complainants) filed a UDRP complaint in relation to ten domain names owned by YPM. A decision of a sole Panelist was given on 14 July 2010 as Sensis Pty Ltd, Telstra Corporation Limited v Yellow Page Marketing B.V, WIPO Case No. D2010-0817 (‘Sensis I’) (here). 

In Sensis I, the original Panel declined to order transfer of the domain names to the complainants. Why? Because they considered that, while the domain names were confusingly similar to the complainants’ YELLOW PAGES trade marks, the respondent had shown sufficient legitimate ‘fair’ use of the domain names to rebut the complainants’ allegations of lack of rights or legitimate interests. This was because the business directory services provided by the respondent were not restricted to Australia and could be accessed from countries outside Australia where YELLOW PAGES is either not registered or subject to fair descriptive use.

Given this finding, the original Panel in Sensis I did not consider the issue of bad faith registration and use. 
Sensis II
Following the outcome in Sensis I, the complainants refiled the complaint. The decision in the refiled case was given on 15 March 2011 and published as Sensis Pty Ltd, Telstra Corporation Limited v Yellow Page Marketing B.V, WIPO Case No. D2011-0057 (‘Sensis II’).

In Sensis II, a 3-member Panel decided that the case could be reheard because: 
·         Following the established principles in Grove Broadcasting Co. Ltd v Telesystems Communications Limited, WIPO Case No. D2000-0703 (here) and Creo Products Inc. v Website in Development, WIPO Case No. D2000-1490 (here), the case could be reheard on the basis that new evidence had come to light regarding the respondent’s conduct since the original complaint was filed in Sensis I.

·         The complainants did not have an opportunity to comment on the original Panel’s own online investigations in Sensis I. The Panel in Sensis II emphasised the importance of procedural fairness in WIPO administrative proceedings. Parties should be allowed to comment on investigations conducted by a Panel of its own initiative that concern ‘new or unanticipated factual or legal material…where that material could be dispositive and where it is reasonably subject to challenge or interpretation’. The parties were not given the opportunity to comment on the original Panel’s own Google and United States Patent and Trademark Office searches in Sensis I. The original Panel in Sensis I relied on these US-focused search results to demonstrate the generic nature of YELLOW PAGES without performing country-specific (i.e. Australia) Google searches, which would have given very different results.
Upon rehearing the case, the Panel in Sensis II ordered transfer of the domain names to the complainants, deciding that: 
·         They agreed with the original Panel in Sensis I regarding confusing similarity.
·         Contrary to the finding in Sensis I, the respondent did not have rights or legitimate interests in the domain names. The Panel in Sensis II did not accept that the respondent was making fair use of the complainants’ YELLOW PAGES mark. Although the respondent’s services could be accessed from outside Australia, new evidence suggested the respondent was operating, and targeting businesses, in Australia. Further, in contrast to the approach of the original Panel in Sensis I, whether YELLOW PAGES was generic in the United States was not relevant to the issue of ‘fair use’ in this case since the disputed domain names were Australia-centric and contained listings and advertisements paid for by local businesses in Australia.

·         The evidence, much of which only came to light after Sensis I, established that the respondent registered and used the domain names in bad faith, seeking to mislead internet users for commercial gain by causing confusion with the complainants’ YELLOW PAGES mark".
Once again, says laden ladenfam, we seem to find a situation in which the complained-of activity is clearly objectionable and deceptive, but the culprits are incredibly difficult to shift. He keeps wondering whether the checks and balances between (i) the need to protect trade marks and trade names, (ii) the need to protect bona fide registration and use of domain names and (iii) the need to safeguard the interests of consumers are in need of radical readjustment to meet the needs of the day.  Merpel adds, does anyone know much money the respondents have been making, and how much of it has been channelled back into the pockets of their victims?

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Australians ask: what should we patent?

Though it never worked as a safety
hat for people learning to swim, this
great Australian invention soon
found an unexpected secondary use
laden ladenfam thanks his Antipodean friend Anna Feros for this link to today's media release from the Australian Government's Advisory Committee on Intellectual Property (ACIP), concerning ACIP's its report on patentable subject matter and its recommendations to amend the Patents Act 1990.  According to the media release, which is headed "What Should be Patented?",
Patent law should be amended to clarify what should and should not be patentable [What! Says Merpel -- won't that take all the fun out of Australian patent law?], an Advisory Council on Intellectual Property (ACIP) report has found. The report on patentable subject matter was released today [nb: it's dated December 2010] by the Chair of ACIP, Mr Leon Allen. 
“There has been recent debate in Australia on the patenting of genes, computer software and business methods”, Mr Allen said today. “Concern has been expressed that mere discoveries or abstract ideas are being patented, and that these patents are hampering access to important innovations and restricting the development of new products [Curiously enough, we Europeans have the same debate and concerns, despite the clarity of expression of the European Patent Convention's lists of (un)patentable subject matter which we've been working from since 1978]. Others say that unethical or offensive inventions can be patented.  ACIP’s recommendations provide a framework to deal with these concerns”.

In conducting the review ACIP received a number of submissions from stakeholders and consulted with them at public discussions in most major capital cities. Key recommendations of the report include: 
• codifying the established principles of patentability – so that an invention must be an artificially created state of affairs in the field of economic endeavour [this looks in principle like an imaginative way of combining the 'products found in nature' issue with 'industrial applicability'] 
• maintaining the current exclusion from patentability of human beings and biological processes for their generation – but not introducing any further specific exclusions [not because the current situation is perfect but because there's no convincing evidence that a shift in either direction would bring better results?]
• introducing a general exclusion from patentability of inventions whose commercial exploitation would be wholly offensive to the Australian public. 
The report also recommends including a statement of objectives in the Patents Act 1990 to outline its purpose, and changes to assist the Commissioner of Patents when applying the test for patentability. 
“ACIP has listened to the concerns of the community, business and other stakeholders, and has sought a balanced approach to take account of their diverse views and interests”, Mr Allen said".
You can read the whole report here.  In an amazing feat of symmetry, it's 95 pages long and has 95 footnotes.  laden ladenfam was interested in the reasoning behind the introduction of a statement of objectives.  The report says at p.3:
"If there is no statement of objectives within the patents legislation, its purpose must be uncovered through secondary sources such as reports to Government, second reading speeches and explanatory memoranda. A statement of objectives is preferable because it conveys the reasons behind Australia’s patent system more transparently. 
A statement of objectives would clarify the interaction between the patent system and competition policy. Including a statement of objectives in the Australian patents legislation would also bring it into line with the practice in other Australian legislation in which objectives clauses, either for a whole Act or a part of an Act, are used. Objectives clauses are also included in the patents legislation of other nations, including Japan, Korea, China, and in the New Zealand Patents Bill".
The Kat wonders how the statement of objectives would compare with the recitals that front Europe's Directives and Regulations, which sometimes seem tiresomely contradictory unless they are taken collectively as a general instruction to the court which interprets them to find the right balance on all occasions when called upon to do so. He also notes ACIP's endorsement of the manner in which the Australian courts have, without formal guidance but on the basis of their flexibility, steered a fairly satisfactory path to date between those things which are generally felt to be patentable and those which are not.

Great Australian inventions here

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Singing the White Shark Grey Goods Blues ...

Great White Sharks can be pretty scary ...
From laden ladenfam's Australian friends at Allens Arthur Robinson comes news of a recent decision that might appeal to his trade mark readers.  It's Sporte Leisure Pty Ltd v Paul's International Pty Ltd (No 3) [2010] FCA 1162, of 20 October 2010.  In this dispute Nicholas J, in the Federal Court of Australia, held that Paul's Retail infringed some 'Greg Norman' registered trade marks held by Great White Shark Enterprises (GWSE) -- even though the allegedly infringing merchandise was made by and bought from an authorised licensee.  Readers will instantly sense the problem here -- parallel importation.  The judge rejected Paul's Retail defence under section 123(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (consent of the trade mark owner) because the licensee of the trade marks was not allowed to sell the goods it made outside the Union of India without consent and knew in advance that the goods made for Paul's Retail were to be sold outside India.

There are three key points to appreciate here:
1. According to the judge, when the registered owner of a trade mark consents to another person applying that mark to goods on condition that those goods must not be supplied outside a designated territory, the trade mark owner is not usually regarded as having consented to the application of the mark to goods which the other person knows, when the mark is applied, are to be supplied outside the territory. However, this a principle may be restricted to the specific facts of this case, because the evidence demonstrated that the licensee only made the goods after receiving a purchase order for them which was to be delivered outside the territory. It is not clear if the same conclusion would apply if the licensee was unaware of the destination of the goods or if the order was met from an existing stockpile.
2. In considering the authorities and concluding that the sole director of Paul's Retail, Paul Dwyer, was not liable for trade mark infringement as a joint tortfeasor, the Court considered that if a director is to be liable as a joint tortfeasor, something more than a finding that the director caused or directed his company to perform infringing acts is required. The extent of the director's personal involvement and his state of mind is important.  Whether the director held an honest belief that the acts which he directed or procured were not unlawful is also a significant (and, in this case, decisive) consideration.
3. Obiter, the court rejected Paul's Retail's submission that there is an onus on GWSE to show that the consent defence under section 123 of the Act does not apply. As a matter of construction, because section 123 of the Act creates an exception to infringement, the burden of proof lies on the person invoking the section.  However, in certain circumstances, it may take little for the evidential burden to shift to the registered owner.
... but laden ladenfam is not
easily intimidated
So now you know.  Says laden ladenfam, in the European Union -- where trade mark enforcement cannot be separated from principles of competition law and protection of the integrity of the single market -- the burden of proof of consent to marketing trade mark-protected goods is a complex issue. In Case C-244/00 Van Doren + Q GmbH v Lifestyle + Sportswear Handelsgesellschaft mbH [2003] ETMR 75, the Court of Justice of the European Communities (as it then was) fixed the burden of proof on the alleged infringer, unless that party could demonstrate that the effect of that burden was to enable the trade mark owner to partition the single market, in which case the burden would shift to the trade mark owner.  The Australians have spared themselves this horror, but there still seem to be some grey areas in grey area consent, as the comments on this decision show.

Great White Shark here
Great White Sharks here
Great White Shark recipe here
Three Little Fishes here [not-to-be-missed performance by Frankie Howerd]

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

The Land of Saints and Sinners? Australia hails Mary

Once upon a time Australia was famous for, among other things, being the distant land to which surplus British criminals could be deported, so that they could be recycled as formidable cricketers, tennis players, IP lawyers and Kylie Minogue. Now, according to the Australian Labor website (via POFnik Mark J. Williams) comes news that the Australian government is to provide special legislative protection to control the use of names associated with Mary MacKillop, who becomes Australia’s first Saint next Monday, 17 October 2010:
"The Corporations Regulations 2001 will be amended so that requests for use of a company name, or part thereof, that suggests a connection to Mary MacKillop will be prevented, unless Ministerial approval [a suitably ordained Minister, the Kat supposes] is granted. A name need not include the text “Mary MacKillop” to suggest a connection. For example, a name including “Saint MacKillop” would be prohibited. A name including “Our Mary” might be blocked, depending on the circumstances and the rest of the text of the name sought. This amendment will reduce the extent to which an entity may hold itself to be associated with Mary MacKillop [What about purchasing MacKillop as a keyword? How will Australian law treat this proposition?].

The Prime Minister said the new measure would provide the highest level of protection currently provided for any individual Australian’s name. The only other individual Australian’s name with similar protection is Sir Donald Bradman [are cricketers such as Sir Don not so much beatified as 'battified' ...].

In addition, existing laws will continue to offer a range of protections against the improper use of Mary MacKillop’s name, including the Trade Marks Act 1995, Trade Practices Act 1974, equivalent state laws, and the common law ..."
laden ladenfam is familiar with the protection of saints' names.  Many highly reputable saints have long enjoyed intellectual property protection as appellations within Europe: thus Saint-Émilion, Saint-Julien and Saint-Romain provide a pleasant accompaniment to Saint-Nectaire and Sainte-Maure de Touraine. Is it in keeping with eternity that the protection of saints' names is generally achieved through rights that have no expiry date or are infinitely renewable?

Merpel says, Europe has produced more saints than all the rest of the world put together, yet they are being exploited without authorisation on a global basis.  Is it not time for a special form of IP registration and protection of saints' names, giving countries other than those of the saints' origins a ten-year period within which they can change the names of the saints they're using or pay a royalty? Organisations could be established for the collective policing and enforcement of saints' names.  The Vatican would doubtless consider such a role, subject to anything the European Commission might have to say about possible abuse of a dominant position.   Another thing to watch out for is the risk of the Chinese developing large numbers of unregistered saints with which to flood markets in the developed world.

The Mary MacKillop story here
Madonna here
The Abandonment of St Michael here

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Attempted Coup Unfolds In Australia

By Darryl Mason

A dramatic night in Australian politics, as the right wing of the Rudd Labor government staged an early evening, non-military coup against the prime minister.

This is how ABC News Online broke the story just before 7pm Sydney time :

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd's leadership is under siege tonight from some of the Labor Party's most influential factional warlords.

The ABC has learned that powerful party figures have been secretly canvassing numbers for a move to dump the Prime Minister and replace him with his deputy, Julia Gillard.

It appears she has rebuffed the advances, but it is a measure of the disquiet which has been building in the party since Mr Rudd's approval ratings began their precipitous slide in April.

Ministers and party members have been lining up all week to voice their support for Mr Rudd but behind the scenes, party leaders have been contemplating a leadership change.

Although Mr Rudd looks likely to survive the challenge, news of the attempted coup will undoubtedly weaken him.

It is understood that the only thing holding the Prime Minister up is that his deputy refuses to join in a bid to bring him down.

That story has been replaced by updates, and the words "attempted coup" have now disappeared from nearly all the frenzied reporting.

Ex-Australian Rupert Murdoch's media has been all but screaming for prime minister Kevin Rudd to be replaced by his deputy, Julia Gillard, for months, declaring across its pages the Rudd government was "over" shortly after prime minister Kevin Rudd's record breaking popularity ratings began to nosedive.

In a dramatic press conference at 9pm Wednesday night, prime minister Kevin Rudd announced that he would let the Labor Party vote for him or Julia Gillard to lead the country to the next election. Gillard is publicly backed by the Murdoch media, right factions of the Labor Party and one of Australia's biggest unions. The conservative opposition will now demand the federal election be held immediately, in the wake of such chaos and disruption, as they should.

The Murdoch media were delighted with the "attempted coup" :





"Defiant Kevin Rudd." Or as he was otherwise known until only a few hours ago, the democratically elected prime minister of Australia.

The Full Story Is Here

Thursday, April 1, 2010

If The Sharks, Snakes, Crocodiles And Serial Killers Don't Get You....

The Australian government launches a new international tourism campaign based around the tag line, "There's Nothing Like Australia". You got that right, mate.







Sunday, February 28, 2010

For the 3rd time since 2004, live fish fell from the sky over a town in the Northern Territory of Australia. The town sits hundreds of kilometres from lakes, and the coast. No tornadoes or any other weather incidents of note that might have been responsible were on weather charts.

A local was quoted as saying : "Thank God it didn't rain crocodiles."

More Here